The method

How this was built, and why you can check it.

The standard

Not mathematical proof. History and philosophy rarely give you that. The standard here is the preponderance of the evidence: which explanation fits the known facts best, explains the most, conflicts with the least, and needs the fewest extra assumptions. Verdicts land on a plain five-point scale, and no miracle is ever smuggled in.

The honesty rule

Respect the person, challenge the proposition. Every religion is described so that someone inside it should recognize it as fair before a single hard question is asked. Every verdict counts the evidence against my own view too, including the parts I would rather ignore.

About the AI

The research skeleton was built with the help of AI working from public sources, then checked, corrected, arranged, and directed by a human author who owns every conclusion. Two independent AI systems were used to argue against each other so the drafts got red-teamed, not rubber-stamped. AI and the internet can be wrong. Shocker, right? That is exactly why the sources are laid out for you to check instead of trusting me.

Start the investigation →